Wednesday, 4 January 2017

Important for May 17 exams - by CA Surbhi Bansal



As you all know, ICAI had published applicable syllabus for CA Exams, May 2017 yesterday. Regarding that CA Surbhi Bansal, well-renowned Faculty of CA Audit exams of our country has posted some important points which one should consider while preparing for exams on her official facebook account.


Her observations on yesterday ICAI official announcement of applicable syllabus:

Important announcement for CA exams May' 2017 :
Board of Studies, ICAI today issued the list of pronouncements, standards, amendments etc. applicable for May'2017 exams and they have not made applicable those new and revised standards wef 1.4.2017 for upcoming attempt. I had already clarified regarding this in my FB post dated 21st November' 2016.
http://www.icai.org/new_category.html?c_id=343
P.S. Readers of my books may please note that revised editions which are available in market for May 2017 exams, contain these amendments which ICAI has made applicable in this formal announcement today. For satellite students at Stargate CA also, we have already sent updated books.


Her facebook post dated 21st November, 2016
IMPORTANT FOR MAY 2017 EXAMS:
1. Recently five Standards on Auditing have been revised ie. SA 260, SA 570, SA 700, SA 705, SA 706 and one SA 701 new has been issued by ICAI. There are changes in the drafting requirements of audit reports under these SAs as compared to the existing ones.
2. All these standards are effective for audits of financial statements for periods beginning on or after April 1, 2017. It implies that practically auditor shall draft his audit report considering these SAs for the first time in 2018 ( i.e. when he will be reporting on the financial statements for 17-18).

3. As per my understanding when he is going to draft his report for current financial year 2016-17 , he will follow the existing standards only ( and not the revised & new ones). Thus, practically drafting as per new standads will be from April 2018 only.
4. Now in the absence of any official announcement by BOS in this regards till today ie November 21st , there are rounds of confusion and students are asking me too as to whether new standards applicable for the audits of financial statements prepared for the period beginning from 1.4.17, ie. 17-18 should be applicable for upcoming May 2017 exams or existing ones. I refrain from answering, better wait for announcement by ICAI in this regard. However, If I go by the general provision and past trend as to the applicability of a particular standard in exams and practical implication of applicability para contained in those standards as mentioned in point number 2, these might not be made applicable for May 2017 exams. Please note that SA 610 ( revised) and SAE 3420 , both effective from 1.4.16 were also not made applicable by ICAI even for November 2016 exams. (though these two wef 1.4.16 should be applicable in may 2017 exams, let's wait for announcement by BOS in this regard as well) So, going by this trend do you think these new ones effective from 1.4.2017 should be applicable in May 2017 exams? I doubt based on past trend. Better to wait for announcement by ICAI. I hope Board of Studies, ICAI will soon update about the same and other amendments on its website.
CONCLUSION: In my opinion, if you are appearing in May 2017 exams, prepare all Standards leaving these ones effective wef 1.4.17 for the time being. Wait for formal announcement by BOS, ICAI in this regard.
PS. This is my honest attempt to explain the situation without drawing any conclusion if these are applicable or not in may 2017. Let's wait till there is any formal announcement by ICAI. Pending clarification, I am sending my books for printing. For those attending classes, we will take up relevant ones in class. For old students, amendment classes shall be provided as always, if required. For any further update regarding amendments, you may visit www.surbhibansal.com or www.stargate.net.in

Source : https://www.facebook.com/surbhibansal123/